by ExIntrepid » Tue Jul 28, 2009 9:03 am
Ok, I'll take this seriously: the whole Idea of Universal Conscription lends itself just as much to abuse as the idea of universal anything. The only thing human beings universally HAVE to do is Die and pay taxes. And I'm pretty sure that a fairish number manage to avoid the latter.
Now, if you suggested that only veterans should have the franchise, now there I can heartily agree with you, personally. On consideration, though, while imiting the power to vote to those who have served SOUNDS good, but I wonder if those who are unwilling to do a hitch would, in the end, accept that limitation. I think it would always be a division in the population that would cause problems.
Then, of course, one would get into the problem people like vegetarians, or animal rights people, or maybe Quakers, who won't fight under any circumstances. Would I be willing to offer them the franchise if they did their service as FOBBITS in some messkit storage facility in their home town, when I earned my voters card getting shot at? I don't think so.
Last; what about the disabled who want to serve? What about criminals? What about the weasles who don't even want to be there? Would you want someone who didn't want to be there and whom you couldn't trust not to run covering your flank when the sh*t hits the fan? Not ME, Kemosabe...
Alternative service not involving risk of life demeans those who do so. And remember Germany's 'Brown Shirts' — One of the things Obama has suggested makes me remember the history of that group and contemplate how that could happen here. Which it could, trust me.
Notice I've said nothing about women serving in combat? That's because I have no question women can serve as well as men can. Note that I'm completely ignoring the 'women should be protected because they're more valuable' argument. That's because, as near as I can tell, we pretty much have enough women that we can afford the risk.
Bottom Line: Serving the country in the military is a personal decision, and I believe that universal conscription is just a state sponsored form of temporary (or not so ....) slavery. And slavery of any kind is an invitation to tyranny.
— ExIntrepid
— ExIntrepid
... for if we find that we have left our bones to bleach in these sands in vain, then beware the fury of the legions.
—Centurion Marcus Flavinius,
2nd Cohort, Augusta Legion